Praise the Effort, Not the Marks

“You are so smart!” feels like the kindest thing to say. Research shows it can make children avoid challenges, give up faster and even cheat. Here is what to say instead.

For every parent8 min read
1

What research found

Most of us praise our children by saying how clever they are. It comes from love. But over 25 years, researchers have tested what different kinds of praise do to children, and the results surprise most parents.

5research studies
480+children tested or filmed
25+years of research
1
What parents believe

Most parents think praising intelligence builds confidence

Columbia University poll of parents, USA · 1990s

85%of parents believed praising ability is necessary
What they found

When Carol Dweck's team at Columbia University polled parents, about 85% said praising their children's ability was needed to make them feel smart. The studies below tested what that praise actually does.

What it means at home
  • If you say “You are so intelligent” often, you are in the majority. You are not a bad parent.
  • The good news: a small change in words makes a real difference.

Source: Dweck (2007), “The Secret to Raising Smart Kids”, Scientific American Mind

2
Praise and giving up

Children praised for being smart gave up faster and lied about their scores

Columbia University, USA · 1998 · 128 fifth-grade children (six experiments in all)

  1. “You're so smart!”
  2. A hard problem feels like proof “I'm not smart”
  3. Child avoids hard work, gives up early
  4. Hides mistakes, even lies about marks

…and needs to hear “smart” again to feel good

What they found

Children solved a set of puzzles and were praised in one of two ways: “You must be smart at this” or “You must have worked hard at this.” Then they got a much harder set, which nobody did well on. Children praised for being smart enjoyed the puzzles less, kept trying for less time, and did worse on the next easy set. When asked to write their score for children at another school, almost 4 in 10 of them made their score look higher than it was.

What it means at home
  • When “smart” is the reason for success, failure must mean “not smart”. So children stop trying hard things.
  • Effort praise tells children: if it's hard, work harder or try another way.

Source: Mueller & Dweck (1998), Journal of Personality and Social Psychology

3
Praise and cheating

Even 3-year-olds praised as “smart” were more likely to cheat

University of Toronto, UC San Diego and Zhejiang Normal University · eastern China · 2017 · 300 children aged 3 and 5

What they found

Children played a guessing game. Some were told “You are so smart,” some were told “You did very well this time,” and some were not praised. Then the researcher left the room, asking the child not to peek at the answer. Hidden cameras showed that 60% of the children told they were smart peeked, compared with about 40% in the other two groups.

What it means at home
  • Children feel they must live up to the label, even if it means cheating.
  • Praising what they did (“You did very well this time”) did not have this effect.

Source: Zhao, Heyman, Chen & Lee (2017), Psychological Science

4
Praise at home, years later

How parents praised toddlers predicted how children faced challenges 5 years later

University of Chicago and Stanford, USA · 2013 · 53 families filmed at home

1–3 yrsage when praise was recorded at home
7–8 yrschildren chose harder tasks and believed they could improve
Class 4better maths and reading in the follow-up
What they found

Researchers filmed parents with their children at home at 14, 26 and 38 months old, and counted every kind of praise. Five years later, at 7 to 8 years old, children who had heard more praise for effort and actions (“You worked hard on that”) preferred challenging tasks and believed ability can grow. A later follow-up found the same children did better in maths and reading in Class 4.

What it means at home
  • The words you use with even a 1-year-old matter.
  • It's not how much you praise, it's what you praise.

Source: Gunderson et al. (2013), Child Development; follow-up Gunderson et al. (2018), Developmental Psychology

2

Real-life examples

Moments every family knows. The same moment, said two ways.

Report card dayRavi, 9

Ravi scored 92 in maths. He runs to show his mother.

✕ What we often say
Super! My son is a genius!

What Ravi hears: I must always look clever. If I get a low mark, it means I'm not.

✓ Try saying
You practised those sums every evening, and it shows! Which one was the hardest?

What Ravi hears: Practice works. Hard things are worth trying.

A low markSneha, 12

Sneha got 54 in science. She hides the paper in her bag.

✕ What we often say
Science is not your cup of tea. Your cousin got 95!

What Sneha hears: I'm just bad at science. Trying won't help.

✓ Try saying
This one didn't go well. Let's look at which questions went wrong and make a plan for next time.

What Sneha hears: A low mark is a problem we can fix together.

A drawingArjun, 5

Arjun shows a drawing of the house with a big purple sky.

✕ What we often say
Wow, you are the best artist in the world!

What Arjun hears: (He soon learns it's said about everything, and stops listening.)

✓ Try saying
You used so many colours in the sky! Tell me about this part.

What Arjun hears: Amma really looked at my work. She's interested in what I do.

3

Through the years

  1. Early years (0–5)

    Praise what they do: “You stacked all the blocks!”, “You kept trying to put on your shoes.” Gunderson's study found these early words still mattered five years later.

  2. School years (6–12)

    This is when marks begin. Ask about the work, not just the number: “Which question made you think hardest?” Praise improvement: 60 to 70 is real progress.

  3. Teen years (13+)

    Teens see through empty praise. Be specific and honest: “Your second draft is much clearer.” Notice the effort they put in even when the result is disappointing.

4

Common mistakes

✕ Instead of

“You're so intelligent!”

✓ Try this

“You worked really hard on this.”

✕ Instead of

“You're a natural at maths.”

✓ Try this

“You found a new way to solve it. Show me how.”

✕ Instead of

Praising only the final marks

✓ Try this

Praise the practice, planning and improvement behind the marks.

✕ Instead of

“Good job!” for everything

✓ Try this

Say exactly what was good, so the praise means something.

✕ Instead of

Hiding or scolding failure

✓ Try this

Treat mistakes as information: “What can we learn from this one?”

5

It's never too late

If you have called your child “genius” or “smart” for years, don't worry. Children's beliefs about effort can change at any age when the words around them change.

  1. 1
    Listen to yourself

    For one day, notice what you praise: the child, or what they did?

  2. 2
    Swap one phrase

    Replace “You're so smart” with “You worked hard on that” or “You didn't give up.”

  3. 3
    Welcome hard things

    At dinner, ask: “What was hard for you today?” Share something hard from your own day.

  4. 4
    Use the word “yet”

    When your child says “I can't do it,” add: “You can't do it yet.”

6

Try this week

Every day this week, praise one specific effort, strategy or improvement, out loud.

  • Instead of “Good boy/girl,” say what they did: “You helped your sister without being asked.”
  • After any test, ask “What did you learn?” before “How much did you get?”
  • Tell your child about something you found hard and kept practising.

A quick self-check

Tick what is true for you today. This is only for you: nothing is saved or shared.

Key ideas

  1. In Columbia studies, children praised as “smart” gave up faster, and almost 4 in 10 lied about their scores.
  2. In China, 60% of 3- and 5-year-olds praised as “smart” peeked to cheat, against about 40% of others.
  3. Toddlers who heard praise for effort chose harder tasks five years later.
  4. Praise the effort, strategy and improvement, honestly and specifically.
  5. When it's hard, add one word: “yet”.

Sources